As reported by CTV Winnipeg the other day, the Manitoba Museum was to host another “Yuri’s Night” at the Planetarium on April 6th. It’s billed as “part of a global celebration of humanity’s past, present and future in space”. Sort of like a Jane’s Walk for space nuts. Yuri, of course, is Soviet cosmonaut Yuri Gagarin, who was the first person in space on April 12, 1961 - almost 65 years to the day of the event.
A small group headed by two Ukrainian women was insulted by the Manitoba Museum hosting a Yuri’s Night event, as Russia is currently at war with Ukraine, and complained. What did the museum do? Rather than try to explain the context and intent of the event, they cancelled it.
This, despite its canned Facebook apology to people who complained stating: "Yuri's Night was never intended to be focused on Yuri Gagarin himself. While he became the first human to orbit the Earth in 1961, the focus is intended to be on this beginning of humankind's exploration of space, which has led humans to walk on the Moon, build space stations, and yearn to explore our solar system. The exploration of space is just one manifestation of the human spirit of exploration; our need to know, to learn, to discover."
Some might think, well Russia is at war, so best not to teach people about Russians in history, and feel that the Museum took some principled stance, but that is not the case. In the very same week as the space history exhibit was to be shown, the Museum held a viewing party for the Artemis II launch. This is a mission crewed by some members of the American military and funded by a regime that has threatened to make Canada the 51st state. It has also inflicted great economic hardship on our country with its tariff policies.
Furthermore, it is a big funder of the Israeli military machine that has been destroying Palestine since 2023, and started a war with Iran, which has spun out of control and caused instability in the entire region. The resulting spike in oil prices will further hurt Canadians.
The fact that one event was cancelled and the other went ahead shows that this wasn't some sort of principled response by the Museum, it just couldn't stick to its guns that an event about the history of space exploration had to include Gagarin. It caved into tenuous complaints.
There are two concerns I have with how this all played out.
The first is how relatively quickly and easily the Museum will alter or edit its programming based on what are pretty tenuous complaints. That cat is now out of the bag, and it will make the Museum a magnet for other groups looking to right wrongs or get back at other groups by having people or events edited out of exhibits.
The second is that the cancelling of Yuri Gagarin's name from its space history programming made the news. What programming or exhibits past, present and future have already been altered due to complaints from other groups, where the complainants did not run to the media?
In the days of online misinformation, organisations like the Museum are the places that need to stand up for history and defend factual information that they are presenting. For me, I will now always wonder when reading something by, or seeing something at, the Manitoba Museum, whether or not events, people, or information has been edited out to appease community complaints.














No comments:
Post a Comment